Blog / Why Platform Doesn't Matter as Much as You Think

Why Platform Doesn't Matter as Much as You Think

November 8, 2026by PickThe.Games

The old argument

"Should I get a PS5 or Xbox?" Ten years ago, this question mattered a lot. Your platform choice determined who you could play with. Buy the wrong console and you were locked out of your friend group's game nights.

That era is ending. Not completely, and not without some frustrating exceptions, but the walls between platforms are lower than they've ever been.

What changed

A few things happened at once.

Crossplay became normal. Fortnite proved it could work at massive scale. Call of Duty followed. Rocket League, Minecraft, Apex Legends. Now most major multiplayer releases either ship with crossplay or add it within a few months. It's no longer a selling point. It's expected. Game Pass blurred the line between Xbox and PC. If you're on Xbox or PC, you're often playing from the same library with the same friends list. The distinction between the two barely exists for multiplayer purposes. Steam Machine arrived. Valve's console runs your Steam library in the living room. If your group is on PC, someone can join from the couch without building a desktop. The hardware barrier dropped. Nintendo Switch 2 launched with better online. The original Switch was a crossplay afterthought. Switch 2 has more titles with proper crossplay support, and developers are treating it as a real online platform rather than a portable novelty.

What's still broken

Not everything is solved. Some realities haven't changed:

  • Some publishers still skip certain combos. A game might support PC-to-PS5 crossplay but not PC-to-Switch 2. Or PS5-to-Xbox but not PS5-to-Switch. Every platform pair is its own situation.
  • Performance gaps cause friction. A Switch 2 player and a PC player in the same shooter lobby are not having the same experience. Some games handle this well. Others don't.
  • Nintendo's online infrastructure is still behind. Voice chat, party systems, and friend management on Switch 2 are better than the original Switch, but still lag behind Xbox and PlayStation.
  • Exclusive titles still exist. You can't play Helldivers 2 on Xbox (at launch, anyway). You can't play Halo on PlayStation. Platform exclusivity hasn't disappeared, it's just less common in the multiplayer space.

The real question now

The question isn't "which platform should I buy" anymore. It's "which games let my specific group play together."

That's a harder question to answer because it depends on exactly which platforms your group is on. PC and PS5? Tons of options. PS5 and Switch 2? Fewer, but growing. Xbox and Switch 2? Somewhere in between.

We built PickThe.Games to solve exactly this. You tell it what platforms your group has, and it shows you what actually works for your combination. The crossplay checker tracks status per platform pair, so you see the real picture instead of guessing.

What this means for buying decisions

If someone in your group is choosing a platform today, the honest advice is: buy whatever has the games you want to play solo, and check crossplay for the games you want to play together. The platform itself is rarely the bottleneck anymore.

The bottleneck is finding a game everyone agrees on. That's the harder problem, and it has nothing to do with hardware.

Try finding one here.

Find games your group can play

Create a board, invite friends, swipe on games. Free.

Related posts